Results and outcomes for Super Bowl 2024 prop bets – The Athletic

By Jay Felicio and Dan SantaromitaFeb 12, 2024

Super Bowl LVIII ended in dramatic fashion in overtime with the Kansas City Chiefs beating the San Francisco 49ers in overtime, but the final score was just one piece of the puzzle if you’re into Super Bowl prop bets. From the time of the national anthem, to the coin toss and the color of the Gatorade bath (which almost didn’t happen this year!), we have the results of all the major Super Bowl prop bets right here.

We had our own Super Bowl party props sheet and the answers to that are below as well as some others that could have been included in your own versions.

Pregame props

Coin flip result: Heads

Reba McEntire’s national anthem goes over 86.5 seconds.

Taylor Swift was not shown on the CBS broadcast during the national anthem.


Reba McEntire does not sing the national anthem a cappella.

Halftime show props

First song: “U don’t have to call”

Last song: “Yeah!”

Usher did not wear sunglasses during his halftime performance.

First guess performer: Alicia Keys

Total songs performed over 8.5 (must include lyrics) during the halftime show.


The result of Gronk’s kick in his “Kick of Destiny 2” FanDuel commercial was a miss.

Soccer star Lionel Messi (Michelob Ultra) appears in a commercial before David Beckham (Uber Eats).

Actress Aubrey Plaza (Mountain Dew) appears in a commercial before Jenna Ortega (Doritos).

In the Nerds “Who is Addison Rae coaching” commercial, Rae was coaching other (It was a Nerds gummy).


Super Bowl 2025 odds: Texans, Eagles and Falcons have biggest swings from last preseason

Player props

First touchdown scorer: Christian McCaffrey

Anytime touchdown scorers: McCaffrey, Jauan Jennings, Marquez Valdes-Scantling, Mecole Hardman

Final touchdown scorer: Hardman

Patrick Mahomes

Over 1.5 touchdowns thrown

Over 262.5 yards passing

Over 36.5 attempts

Over 26.5 yards rushing

Over 12.5 yards longest rush

Over 0.5 interceptions

Longest pass goes over 36.5 yards

Brock Purdy

Under 1.5 touchdowns thrown

Over 247.5 yards passing

Over 30.5 pass attempts

Under 12.5 yards rushing

Under 0.5 interceptions

Longest pass goes under 37.5 yards

George Kittle

Under 50.5 yards receiving

Under 3.5 catches

Under 21.5 yards longest catch

Deebo Samuel

Under 58.5 yards receiving

Under 4.5 catches

Under 21.5 yards longest catch

Brandon Aiyuk

Under 61.5 yards receiving

Under 4.5 catches

Under 24.5 yards longest catch

Rashee Rice

Under 67.5 yards receiving

Under 6.5 catches

Under 21.5 yards longest catch

Travis Kelce

Over 70.5 yards receiving

Over 6.5 catches

Over 20.5 yards longest catch

Isaiah Pacheco

Under 65.5 yards rushing

Over 87.5 rushing + receiving yards

Over 15.5 rushing attempts

Under 15.5 yards longest rush


Christian McCaffrey

Under 91.5 yards rushing

Over 18.5 rushing attempts

Over 130.5 rushing + receiving yards

Under 17.5 yards longest rush

Postgame props

Super Bowl MVP: Patrick Mahomes

Gatorade color on winning coach Andy Reid: Purple


Winning squares: First quarter 0-0; halftime 49ers 0, Chiefs 3; third quarter 49ers 0, Chiefs 3; final score 49ers 2, Chiefs 5

The 25-22 final score isn’t an NFL Scorigami, but it is the first time 2-5 (or 5-2) had hit in any quarter in Super Bowl history.

Total field goals made: over 6.5

Shortest touchdown: over 1.5 yards

Last turnover of the game: Fumble (technically it was a muffed punt, but it was in the official box score as a lost fumble).

Who will have a longer pass completion: Patrick Mahomes or Brock Purdy? Mahomes, with a 52-yard completion to Mecole Hardman.

Will any of the following events occur in the game: Safety, Flea Flicker Attempt, Field Goal Doink, Defense TD, Special Teams TD: No

First team to score: 49ers

First team to reach 10 points: 49ers

First team to reach 20 points: 49ers

First team to score a touchdown: 49ers

First team to punt: Chiefs

Longest field goal: Over 47.5 yards (Jake Moody hits a Super Bowl-record 55-yard field goal, Harrison Butker also made a 57-yard field goal to break Moody’s record)

First penalty flag of the game was a false start.

Iconic Las Vegas landmark seen on the broadcast first during the game: Luxor pyramid/sphinx

Will SpongeBob be shown on the CBS broadcast during the game? Yes

First person shown sitting directly next to Taylor Swift during the game: Blake Lively

Will Taylor Swift be shown in the stadium before the final whistle wearing clothing that bears Travis Kelce’s name, number, image or likeness? Yes


How the Chiefs stack up among NFL dynasties (and a path past the Patriots): Sando’s Pick Six

(Photo of Andy Reid: Michael Reaves / Getty Images)

Get all-access to exclusive stories.

Subscribe to The Athletic for in-depth coverage of your favorite players, teams, leagues and clubs. Try a week on us.

Start Free Trial