What next for Gareth Southgate? An England exit or 2026 World Cup bid? – The Athletic

By Jack Pitt-BrookeMar 27, 2024

Get your questions in for Alan Shearer, who is holding a Q&A from 3pm (GMT) where he’ll discuss England, the Premier League title race and who should go to the Euros

It did not feel at Wembley on Tuesday night as if we were entering the final phase of the Gareth Southgate era.

It felt more like this is a process that is still being endlessly worked on. One that does not just have one end-point in sight — at the Olympiastadion in Berlin on July 14, less than four months from now — but has a further horizon, too, most likely East Rutherford, New Jersey, on July 19, 2026, almost 10 years after Southgate first took the England job.


That may sound very distant but an unavoidable question, or series of questions, has reared up over this international break: will Euro 2024 be the last of Southgate’s four major tournaments in charge? Will he do enough to earn a new contract to take him through to the next World Cup? Would the English public support his continuance in the job? And, if not, would Southgate be tempted to jump ship into club football?

Southgate watches on as England draw 2-2 with Belgium (Michael Regan – The FA/The FA via Getty Images)

We did not get answers to all of these questions this month, but there were moments Southgate provided some hints.

When Southgate announced his squad for this break here at Wembley he revealed that talks between himself and the Football Association over a new deal beyond this year have been shelved until after the European Championship. Southgate even suggested fears of a possible backlash from England fans if he did sign a new deal before the tournament were part of his thinking.

Last Friday evening, before the Brazil game, Southgate was asked about his links with Manchester United. He did almost as much as he could to shut the talk down, saying he thought it was “completely disrespectful” to Erik ten Hag and that he would not talk to a club while he was still England manager. Assuming there is no way he leaves this post until after the Euros, it is almost impossible to see how he takes a big club job in time for next season.

How to follow Euro 2024 on The Athletic

  • Euro 2024 news and features
  • Euro 2024 fixtures and schedule

He does not look like he is about to ‘do a Julen Lopetegui’, the Spain coach who was sacked right at the start of Spain’s 2018 World Cup campaign when it emerged he had secretly agreed a deal to take over at Real Madrid at the end of the tournament.

So nothing will be decided until after the Euros, one way or the other. There is some enthusiasm about a potential new deal, especially from the FA and the players, Southgate is also wary that the broader public do not necessarily feel the same way. Under-perform in Germany, any outcome short of the final stages, and it will be difficult to sell the merits of his staying on.

Jude Bellingham scored England’s late equaliser (Crystal Pix/MB Media/Getty Images)

That might make people think that all of Southgate’s eggs are being placed in the German basket. Because if he senses that this is his last shot at winning a tournament with England — that he knows he is running out of time with the English football public, that he thinks he has five weeks in Germany to complete his legacy — then that might push him towards a certain short-term approach to decision-making.


If he only needs to worry about the next four months, he might as well just stick with experienced players, known quantities, and go to Germany with the personnel he has taken to tournaments in the past.

The evidence of this week is that is not what he intends.


Southgate has continued to experiment and try out new players, even this late in the day. All the attention will be on Kobbie Mainoo, the 18-year-old midfield sensation who made his first England start against Belgium and took to it instantly. Mainoo adds a lot to this squad already, and Southgate talked about his “ability to receive under pressure, ride challenges, and to manipulate the ball in tight areas”. But as good as he has been, it still might have been safer for England to go for someone with more experience.

Mainoo impressed on England debut (Julian Finney/Getty Images)

Elsewhere Southgate gave debuts to Ezri Konsa and Anthony Gordon, ensuring he had a good look at both, as well as calling up Jarrad Branthwaite. There are plenty of more experienced options, particularly at centre-back, to whom he could have returned if he just wanted sure things for the Euros.

When you look at these selections together, it does suggest Southgate might have an eye on the next cycle, from Berlin 2024 to New Jersey 2026, rather than seeing this summer as the great cut-off line.

Even listening to Southgate talking at Monday’s press conference about the importance of the emergence of the next generation of leaders, the players younger than Harry Kane, Harry Maguire, Kieran Trippier and Kyle Walker, you can see he has an eye on the future. It was Declan Rice who led England out at Wembley on Tuesday, but clearly the leadership qualities of Jude Bellingham are highly rated too, not least for the competitive mentality he showed in dragging England through to their stoppage-time equaliser.


These long-term questions matter to Southgate: about the shape of the team down the line, about the group dynamics, the pathways and succession plans.

Maybe he is just being a selfless custodian, wanting to make sure the team is in a good place for whoever takes over if Germany is indeed his last tournament in charge. Or maybe he has a sense in his mind of what he wants the 2026 team to be, possibly even with Mainoo in midfield, and he wants to be there to see it.


The Briefing: England 2 Belgium 2: Toney and Mainoo shine – but where does this leave Southgate?

(Top photo: Alex Livesey – Danehouse/Getty Images)

Get all-access to exclusive stories.

Subscribe to The Athletic for in-depth coverage of your favorite players, teams, leagues and clubs. Try a week on us.

Start Free Trial

Jack Pitt-Brooke is a football journalist for The Athletic based in London. He joined in 2019 after nine years at The Independent.